“I’ve been one poor correspondent” – as far as this blog goes. When my calendar alerted me, yet again, that today is the third Saturday in the month and designated for song stories, I looked back and saw that I haven’t posted one since I (re)posted about “Christmastime” back in December.
This year, 2026, I’ve written only one song (so far). “Maybe She Is” tells the story of a man spending the day at the airport in Nashville, waiting for the return from Boston of a love he’d lost. Then she’s on the phone again and again, leaving messages suggesting that maybe that’s not the case. She said she was coming in on a Friday in December, but she didn’t tell him the time or the flight number. So, he goes in the morning and waits.
The first verse sets up his day:
I pulled my Honda into long-term parking
Just after sunrise
Above the Nashville skyline two starts still shone
Like the light in her eyes
She was flying in from Boston
Coming home for Christmas
At least that’s what her message said
So I thought, maybe she is
The second verse sets up the singer’s repetitive day, emphasized by something we’re all familiar with – hearing the same Christmas songs over and over and over.
I made my way to the arrivals board
And stood there looking up
Took a seat alone at the terminal bar
And ordered my first cup
I heard Johnny Mathis singing
“I’ll Be Home for Christmas”
I hummed along a harmony
And hoped that . . .
I tried a couple of different classic singers to reference in this verse – Bing Crosby, first, then Frank Sinatra. Both of these might have versions a bit more widely known than that of Johnny Mathis. But the truth is, I grew up on Mathis’s Merry Christmas (released in October 1958, just a little over a month before my birth in November), and it’s his version I always hear in my dreams and daydreams of Christmases at home in Walnut with Mom, Dad, Jerry, and Mama Reeves. So, it’s Johnny Mathis here in “Maybe She Is.”
Maybe she is chatting
With the businessman beside her
Maybe she is in the window seat
Looking down on West Virginia
Maybe she is picturing me
Awaiting her arrival
Maybe she is playing with her hair
Anticipating our reunion . . .
Yeah, maybe she is
Okay, so she wasn’t on that first flight.
I returned to the arrivals board—five hours
’Til the next flight’s here
Then retreated to the terminal bar
And ordered my first beer
I heard Elvis Presley singing
“I’ll Be Home for Christmas”
To the mirror behind the bar
I raised my glass . . .
Now back to what I guess I’ll call Bridge Two.
Maybe she is frantic
To rebook the morning flight she missed
Maybe she is wondering how
To pass one empty hour to the next
Maybe she is lonely
By a bank of silent pay phones
Maybe she is closing her blue eyes
And hanging up on my machine . . .
Yeah, maybe she is
A couple of things here. The story of this song is set in 1993, hence the pay phones. If you’re old enough, you might remember lines of pay phones at various places around our airports. So, the idea is that she’s called him, but given that he’s at the airport, his machine picked up at his apartment on Nashville’s Music Row. If she left a message about her plans, he won’t hear it until later. Also in Bridge Two, I think (I hope), is the suggestion that she won’t be on the afternoon flight either.
Bridge Three changes musical settings again. The voice ranges a little higher, so there’s a little more tension. The five chord is left out, replaced by the flat seven chord, which darkens things a bit. That is, in the key of D, the focus through the verses and the bridges so far is on the one chord (D), the five chord (A), and the four chord (G). But in this third iteration of the bridge, the focus shifts to D, C, and G, which, to my mind and ear, gives the section a more haunted feeling, a greater sense of longing.
So, the day’s last flight from Boston should be on its way:
Maybe she is losing the moon
And descending through the belly of clouds
Maybe she is touching down in Music City
With her engines roaring loud
Or maybe she is at a Boston café
A wine glass in her hand
Enjoying artsy conversation and a busker band
Finally, we come to the end of the day, the last flight from Boston, the final verse.
I stood at the arrival gate for the last flight
In from Boston
And watched a stream of passengers deplane to waiting
Arms of loved ones
I heard Alan Jackson singing
“I’ll Be Home for Christmas”
And when the stream slowed to a trickle
Then I thought, maybe she is . . .
Maybe she is . . .
Maybe she is . . .
So, I’ve sort of left it up to the listener to decide. Maybe she is holding back, nervous about this reunion or not even sure that he has come to meet her. Maybe she is waiting to be last for dramatic Romcom effect. Maybe she is not on the plane and not coming home for Christmas after all.
Here’s the whole thing together.
I pulled my Honda into long-term parking
Just after sunrise
Above the Nashville skyline two starts still shone
Like the light in her eyes
She was flying in from Boston
Coming home for Christmas
At least that’s what her message said
So I thought, maybe she is
I made my way to the arrivals board
And stood there looking up
Took a seat alone at the terminal bar
And ordered my first cup
I heard Johnny Mathis singing
“I’ll Be Home for Christmas”
I hummed along a harmony
And hoped that . . .
Maybe she is chatting
With the businessman beside her
Maybe she is in the window seat
Looking down on West Virginia
Maybe she is picturing me
Awaiting her arrival
Maybe she is playing with her hair
Anticipating our reunion . . .
Yeah, maybe she is
I returned to the arrivals board—five hours
’Til the next flight’s here
Then retreated to the terminal bar
And ordered my first beer
I heard Elvis Presley singing
“I’ll Be Home for Christmas”
To the mirror behind the bar
I raised my glass . . .
Maybe she is frantic
To rebook the morning flight she missed
Maybe she is wondering how
To pass one empty hour to the next
Maybe she is lonely
By a bank of silent pay phones
Maybe she is closing her blue eyes
And hanging up on my machine . . .
Yeah, maybe she is
Maybe she is losing the moon
And descending through the belly of clouds
Maybe she is touching down in Music City
With her engines roaring loud
Or maybe she is at a Boston café
A wine glass in her hand
Enjoying artsy conversation and a busker band
I stood at the arrival gate for the last flight
In from Boston
And watched a stream of passengers deplane to waiting
Arms of loved ones
I heard Alan Jackson singing
“I’ll Be Home for Christmas”
And when the stream slowed to a trickle
Then I thought, maybe she is . . .
Maybe she is . . .
Maybe she is . . .
This lyric ends the novel I just finished. It’s an Ezra MacRae novel, a sequel to Streets of Nashville, so this is an Ezra MacRae song. The working title to the novel, taking place four years after the main events in Streets, is Jacob’s Limp. Not sure if that title will remain. Not sure, of course, if the novel will even be published. But if it is picked up for publication, I don’t expect that it would be out until 2028, so, this post is unlikely to serve as spoiler for two reasons: first, it doesn’t say whether she—Sally—was on the plane or not, and two, I doubt anybody who reads this in 2026 will remember it in 2028.
I wrote three drafts of Jacob’s Limp without having an ending. Not until I was near to the completion of the fourth draft did I have the aha moment that led to the ending featuring this song. It’s an ambiguous conclusion to the novel, but I hope it’ll still be satisfying to readers—if it ever finds readers.
Here’s hoping!
P.S. I have music to this, too, of course. Somebody recently suggested to me the idea that I should record this and upload it to a secure and stable place on the internet. At the end of the novel, a QR code could be included to allow readers to hear the song when they’ve finished the novel. That’s a great idea!











